Friday, June 21, 2013

Review: The Returned

The Returned
The Returned by Jason Mott

My rating: 2 of 5 stars

After watching that awesomely creepy book trailer for The Returned, I knew I had to read this! Unfortunately, for me, the book didn't quite live up to the promise of the trailer. The story is kind of strange, as you would expect from a story about people returning from the dead, but it had the potential to be so much more than it was.

The story reminds me of that show from some years back called The 4400 where people that had disappeared and were assumed dead began reappearing the same age they were when they left. This is exactly what happens in The Returned except those returning were definitely dead and buried, yet somehow they are back. Each chapter began with snippets of events throughout the world which highlighted the rising panic, mistrust of the returned, and the worldwide population problem this situation would present. I would have enjoyed seeing this explored further. However, most of the story's focus was on one small town where government authority, anti-government militia, and average citizen on both sides of the problem all come together.

It took me over a week to plod through The Returned. One of the things didn't work for me is the same thing that always makes me lose interest in the story, a lack of connection to the characters. The premise was interesting enough, but I needed more than one dimensional characters to pull me into the story and make me feel any kind of way about it. Instead, I felt like I had read a news article discussing what happened with a few quotes from witnesses. I think that if there would have been more "showing" than telling, I could have enjoyed it more. As it was, the delivery was a bit flat, I didn't care about the characters, and so The Returned just didn't work for me.

I have heard this was very quickly optioned for a TV series and I am interested to see how that pans out. I think this will translate much better to TV because the actors will be able to breathe life and personality into these characters on screen. Perhaps the right music and dramatic dialog will also add some nuance to what was, for me, a rather colorless story.

View all my reviews


Kate Midnight Book Girl said...

It does sound interesting, but I'll probably wait for the tv show. ;) I just wish they'd let shows build up an audience, because the 4400 was taken before it's time.

Sam said...

I caught this on TV not too long ago and really liked it, so I was curious about the book. I'm really glad I got your opinion as I can tell that it won't work for me at all. It sounds quite lifeless and boring, more than anything. I hope the TV series will work better for you. :)

Donna Smith said...

@Kate Midnight Book Girl

It was interesting Kate, and had the potential to be such a good book but somehow failed to deliver. I was SO bored with it, I almost DNF'ed it several times. I only caught a few episodes of the 4400 but enough that this really reminded me of it.

Donna Smith said...


Sam, we do tend to have similar tastes in books quite often. I expected a lot more from this one since it has such an interesting premise and since the author is known for his poetry I thought the book would flow a bit better than it did. I expect the TV show will be better.

FTC Disclaimer - I do receive some books directly from the authors or publishers for review purposes. Each review posted is my own personal opinion and any books I accept are not guaranteed a positive review. I do not receive monetary gain from reviewing those books I accept.
I include affiliate links to Amazon in my reviews and other posts. Those links will take the reader to and I do receive a small percentage of each purchase.